This isn’t really a thread designed to debate whether or not the feat deserves to be removed, it’s a thread debating the merits of whether or not his suggestion should be implemented. A separate thread should be created to discuss the merits of removing the feat if that is everyone’s desire, and such thoughts may be conveyed there instead of burying the purpose of this thread under our combined, weightless debates.
That being said, I’ll leave my disagreement with the brief elaboration that the primary complaints regarding it seem to revolve around the way the feeding interacts with a corpse to potentially badly impair them. If that’s a large enough issue, they can correct that independently of removing the feat. Insofar as antagonistic roleplay is concerned, the stat buffs that come along with Voracious aren’t particularly gamebreaking. In the long run the +2 CON and +2 STR bonuses are the difference of a few HP, 1 Fort save bonus, and +1 AB and +1 Damage (For STR-based melee) or just +1 Damage for DEX-based melee.
I disagree with the notion that playing a controversial or antagonistic PC should be exclusively relegated to the realms of DP’s and (a)MPC applications. I believe this offers new narrative opportunities, especially for Caliban and the like who would reasonably be cannibals.
Whomsoever takes this feat is subjecting themselves to the same treatment open necromancers, red wizards, Blackguards and Banites get on this server which is complete and total annihilation by the masses if they remain among them. In my humble opinion, they can have the 1 AB and 10 HP. They’re gonna need it.