On 18 Decembre 779, the trial of Cordelia Smith for the murder of Borcan sailor Sostrato Di Santis is helmed by Magistrate Louis Joseph du Roquefort, Baron de Vexin on behalf of the Cour du Justice. In a rare display, Mlle. Smith largely allows this particular battle to be fought by her legal representative, Gris Quarpied, an elderly Petits Personne transitioned from advocate for the State to defense solicitor. Mlle. Mariah Parsons leads the prosecution on behalf of the Gendarmerie Nationale. While the defense's strategy to paint Mlle. Smith as a young woman caught up in the glory of a dueling culture is largely countered by the prosecution's repudiations, testimonial miss step leaves the Gendarmerie Nationale with a black eye while Quarpied himself risks upsetting the nobility with his attempts to shift blame to those gentry who shared Mlle. Smith's company. The palette is muddied by Quarpied's legally dubious invocation of Dementlieu's treaty obligations to Borca, and the Gendarmie Nationale's reimbursement of the Stapan to Sostrato Di Santis indenture.
In the end, Mlle. Smith is convicted, though the Magistrate suspends her sentence in what is largely seen as a stopgap measures to avoid any wider diplomatic incident cushioned by the accused's own contrite admission of guilt and calls for clemency. The Magistrate's own decree mandates that the Gendarmerie Nationale ensure any further duels within its jurisdiction are fought in Dementlieuse style and conduct, with civilized weapons such as pistol or épée rather than 'medieval' implements. While efforts to curtail dueling (largely the domain of soldiery and the more hot-blooded and antique gentry) have failed in the past, there is little contention among the the enlightened of Port-a-Lucine to the notion a gentleman should carry a gentleman's weapon.
That Mlle. Smith was allowed trial at all is not-so-subtle credence to the influence of her employers at the Plume d'Or, while others question just how Gris Quarpied came to have such intimate understanding of the details of the Gendarmerie Nationale's investigative activities within the seedy confined of the Quartier Ouvrier.