I'll admit that the server has some minor things, but in general it is very nice. I have played here off and on since oh. . .what i think 2004/ 2005? Something like that.
Still, the role play from some people is quite phenomenal, and some of the dm events are as well. Have I had chars which have been perma'd, yeah, but then that's how it use to be, not so much any more. And though I don't really like that going away it's how things have progressed.
I certainly don't think the server deserves a 1 in any regard, I'm thinking some where between an 8 and 9, but that's my vote. Maybe I'll try to remember my vault sign on and write my own review
Nothing is ever perfect, and many, many things are still in the works from my understanding, and I am all curiousness about what is going to come next.
I will give some merit to the idea that there may be a group of high levels which enjoy roaming around, and tagging dungeons. But if that's what they want to do then no one is going to stop them, unless its a dm.
Besides, if people look, and mind you exploring can be nerve wracking when you have no idea what could be out there some times, because you worry if you'll survive or get xp for it, there are some amazingly built dungeons and areas which give the server a life which wont be seen any where else, most likely ever.
I would love to get involved in some of the dm events which are going on currently, though a crafter who is always making things is rarely in the loop about oddities which are going on. But who knows, maybe one of my chars will find something unusual in cave with iron ore.