I've noticed something wrong with the damage output of Cavalry Saber weapon. The stats of the rapier are the following:
- 1d4 slashing
- enhancement penalty -1
- 1d10 massive criticals
- Extra Melee damage: slashing
The issue I find is with the low output of critical damage, which reaches as low as 4 and 8. The testing was done with GMW +3 and with a character with +1 str modifier, with no other modifiers influencing the damage ; opposing resistances included. I'm not sure whether 1d4 slashing is also multiplied by crit modifier, but If I'm not wrong, the calculation for minimal critical damage (Without 1d4 slashing involved) should be as following:
(1 (1d6) + 1 (str modifier) + 2 physical (GMW +3 - 1 EB) ) x 2 + 1 (1d10) =
9I will try to replicate the Kobold cave instance where I've gotten 4 damage on a critical roll. I crashed after it, so I lost the contents of log before screencapping.